Embedded Files
As a Mechanical Engineer, my role involves a precise and multifaceted approach in estimating and tendering for various projects. My experience covers:
General Take-off:
Identification: Recognizing various components required for the systems, such as pipes, wires, ducts, fixtures, etc.
Measurement: Carefully measuring quantities, sizes, and lengths of these components.
Scale Verification: It is vital to double-check the scale of the drawing to ensure precise calculations.
Calculation: Calculating the associated costs based on quantities and specifications.
Equipment Take-off:
Analysis: Reviewing specifications, drawings, and requirements for each piece of equipment, including complex units that often have the highest impact on project costs.
Evaluation: Ensuring alignment with EN/BS/ASHRAE/SMACNA standards and relevant regulations.
Selection: Choosing suitable equipment that meets both technical needs and budget constraints.
Duct Take-off:
Calculation: Estimating the required duct areas in square meters and weights, considering various materials like galvanized steel, aluminum, flexible ducting, etc.
Scale Verification: Verifying the PDF scale to prevent incorrect results.
Pipes & Accessories Take-off:
Determination: Determining quantities needed for different pipes (chilled water, plumbing, drainage, firefighting), including valves, connectors, fittings, insulation, etc.
Coordination: Collaborating with suppliers to ensure proper procurement.
Specialized System Take-off (Firefighting & Plumbing Systems):
Design & Planning: Analyzing and evaluating required components, adhering to relevant codes and standards.
Consideration of Specific Requirements: Assessing various project-specific elements, including water supply, drainage, sanitary fittings, sprinklers, hoses, etc.
Technology Integration:
Software Utilization: Leveraging specialized software to streamline the process.
Spreadsheet Templates: Creating templates to list all required items, easing procurement.
10. Evaluation of Quotations:
i. Technical Aspects:
Specification Analysis:
Matching Requirements: Ensuring that the quoted items strictly match the required specifications such as size, material, capacity, performance, efficiency, and applicable standards.
Alternative Solutions Scrutiny: Evaluating alternative solutions provided by suppliers, assessing their compatibility, performance, and potential impact on the system's functionality.
Compliance Check: Verifying that all quoted items are in line with relevant codes and regulations (EN/BS/ASHRAE/SMACNA) for the particular system, whether it's HVAC, plumbing, or fire suppression.
Equipment Complexity: Understanding that each piece of equipment is a complex unit with multiple components that must be accurately defined and matched to ensure seamless integration into the system.
Cross-Verification:
Drawings and Bills of Quantities: Comparing the quotes with original drawings, specifications, and bills of quantities to validate alignment.
Scale Verification in Take-Off: Ensuring that the quoted quantities align with the take-off, double-checking the scale of drawings to prevent inaccuracies.
ii. Commercial Aspects:
Brand and Country of Origin (COO) Compliance:
Brand Consistency: Ensuring that quoted brands match those required by the project, considering performance and suitability.
COO Impact: Recognizing that the COO affects pricing and quality. For example, a Carrier HVAC unit from China may differ in price from a Carrier unit from Italy.
Price and Supplier Analysis:
Incoterms Consideration: Understanding and accounting for International Commercial Terms (Incoterms) which define responsibilities for shipping, insurance, documentation, customs clearance, and other logistical activities. These terms can significantly influence the final cost and must be carefully evaluated.
Complete Cost Understanding: Analyzing all cost components, including manufacturing, logistics, taxes, and hidden charges.
Supplier Reliability: Assessing suppliers' market reputation, alignment with quality standards, and readiness for detailed negotiations and contract formation.
Contractual and Ongoing Oversight:
Negotiation Strategy: Crafting mutually beneficial terms, including payment conditions and lead times.
Continuous Monitoring: Ensuring supplier adherence to agreements, and making necessary adjustments for alignment with the project's timeline and budget.
11. Collaboration and Coordination:
Internal Communication: Aligning with internal teams, such as the buying department.
External Collaboration: Negotiating with suppliers and sub-contractors.
12. Ongoing Oversight and Revision:
Monitoring: Continuously updating the take-off to reflect changes during the project lifecycle.
Quality Assurance: Ensuring accuracy, quality, and adherence to standards.
The meticulous process of Cost Breakdowns and Takeoffs serves as the cornerstone for successful project execution in mechanical engineering. From the general take-off, requiring precise identification, measurement, and scale verification, to the intricate selection of equipment and consideration of ducting and piping, every step is paramount. The deployment of technology integration streamlines this process, while the dual technical and commercial evaluation of quotations ensures alignment with all specifications, including brand and COO considerations. Through strategic collaboration and continual oversight, the process integrates a multitude of factors that are essential for quality, efficiency, and adherence to budget constraints. This comprehensive approach underscores the necessity of accuracy, foresight, and diligence in all facets of project planning and execution.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse